
Wednesday, January 17, 2007
Podcasting nonsense/Oh No..Cucumber Sandwiches!

The world's favourite travel destination (or where I'd like to go)

Tuesday, January 16, 2007
It was only a matter of time..

Well, it had to happen. Someone's decided to parody the Dove ad:
Made me happy at least. It does pose a question though - where do you move the campaign to now if you are Dove? I appreciate that the Campaign for Real Beauty as a strategic idea has legs; despite seemingly being very obvious (the essence and charm of the whole campaign, in my view).
The only (slight) problem I could forsee with this all is if Dove become po-faced like Coke did after the Mentos discovery, and start discouraging parodies like the one above, adopting a sort of Oprah inspired, holier than thou voice. I don't think it will, but I do think the brand will have to be very careful about who it associates with (unlike Coke, who should have milked that Mentos thing for all it was worth).
Such is the weight behind the brand that to move it from a traditional luxury product (see below) to a heavyweight, one for all utilitarian brand was quite something.

However, that's not to say that the brand can associate with just any event or service. Indeed, the fact the brand is now deemed so universal could work against it if the future communications is clumsy or the media spend unfocused.
It's what I'd term a 'pedestal' brand at the moment; in such a great, overarching position that by associating with an event or person overly (yes, I know, it associates with EVERYONE at the moment - I think this may change at some point and become more on one or two brand spokespeople), it'll turn off those who previously supported it from its prior 'one for all' comms output.
That said, I don't think it has a massive risk. Associate wisely, accentuate the campaign in other important avenues (sponsoring certain TV programmes/fun runs and the like) and it'll be just fine.
Sunday, January 14, 2007
Interview Thoughts 2: So Why & Where?


The power of conversation, of a dialogue with a consumer rather than a ‘top down’, dictatorial and enforced message is something which I feel strongly about. In this new communications era, I believe that the ability to generate conversations in order to engage with your consumer will be incredibly important. Indeed, what will continue to endure will be authenticity and storytelling; if you can't do this, you are liable to be found out, as Sony found out here.

Saturday, January 13, 2007
Interview thoughts 1: Magners & Kodak..

As reported in the prior post, I had an interview yesterday. However, I wanted to write a little bit more about my thoughts on some of the topics that were discussed, as well as linking to some of the source material I was chuntering on about.
x
Well, first and foremost, Magners.
Let's look at the line. 'Time Dedicated to You'. As discussed, I don't believe this line has had much impact on the brand's tremendous success. It sounds to me like they came up with the execution/the idea first, then tacked this onto the end of it.
However, let's consider the market before Magners' tremendous success. I've got a little bit of an inside track here, as one of my father's clients was Thatchers, one of Magners' closest rivals. Essentially, there was a two-fold market for cider before Magners. The first was the mainstay of the more traditional ciders such as Thatchers sales, that segment of the market that were liable to be CAMRA members, between the age of 35 to 70, possibly bearded, and definitely the antithesis of lad culture. The second segment who drank cider (and, before Magners, made up the majority of the cider market) were those who used cider predominately as a mixer. In this case, they preferred Strongbow & Black.
Now, Magners has been able to add a layer of sophistication to its offering by effectively turning cider into a long drink, making it far more of a social activity. Though the line appears to be a bit vacuous and tacked on, it does encapsulate the newly created market. I would imagine the creative agency (or indeed, Magners themselves) had the executional idea before anything else.
And indeed, there's the ultra simplistic approach - Magners were the first brand to actually explain just how the cider making process occurs, and how straightforward it is. Couple that with promoting the youth/Irishness angle in the executions whilst helping to create a new category of drinker emphasises, in my view, why the campaign has been a success. The strategic proposition would undoubtedly have been something along the lines of: "Create a new market for cider drinkers" or something similiar.
Magners managed to change the image of cider as profoundly as the reinvention of Lucozade from a medicinal supplement to a sports drink, changing attitudes to the sector from niche to mainstream. It remains to be seen if this will continue to endure; but one thing is for certain - no other drink is like Magners.
Moving on to Kodak, which was the brand I mentioned that I'd like to work on at the moment (not to mention the Independent, The Economist, Morrisons and others which escaped me at the time). Let's have a look at their most recent output, an internal video which was intentionally leaked to YouTube:
That piece of work was created by Partners & Napier. More on it can be found here. Thanks again to Jess for pointing it out to me.
The last thing I knew about Kodak's strapline was that it was now 'Keep it digital', which to me seemed rather strange when you consider the amount of cultural capital tied up in the brand. After all, this is the brand which has had songs written about its products and used them to sell it, as well as essentially owning the connection between memories and pictures - the 'Kodak moment'.

I expressed in the interview that this brand would be fun to work on given the challenges it faces and the amount of cultural capital still tied up in the name. Kodak, I believed, should go after the colour making process - after all, Kodachrome was the first amateur colour film. Surely a base can be built around that?
However, the potential challenge was discussed. Surely Sony could blow Kodak out of the water when it came to owning this colour process? This could be especially problematic, given that they have probably produced the best ad for emphasising colour richness in recent memory.

Perhaps then Kodak could continue to target the Baby Boomer generation, those who grew up knowing the Kodak was a brand leader in the production not only of film, but of cameras as well? I made the suggestion that Kodak could ape 35mill cameras by producing digital versions of them (physically bigger cameras like 35 mill, but with a digital backscreen), perhaps even continuing to produce 35mill cameras while all other manufacturers discard it. However (especially in the case of the latter), this would prove to be an anachronism - effectively giving the company's photography segment a shelf life of 5-7 years.
That said, the notion of dwelling on your heritage isn't a wholly bad idea, just so long as it can be expressed in a new way. I feel that the new Old Spice campaign is able to emphasise this both online and on TV:
And Kodak certainly has the background to be able to do this. Check out the Science & Technology section on their website; they should have a vested interest in making sure their colour credentials are underlined. Far more so than Sony's.
The 'Keep it Forever. Keep it Kodak' line is ok, but it doesn't underline Kodak's history, nor attempt to give a really thoughtful reason as to why consumers should buy their product - to me, it seems to suggest that the reason Kodak think you'll want to buy the camera is because you need something which will never change/be reliable. Digital photography is the antithesis of this.
That rather old fashioned approach aside, the company isn't as antiquated as you may believe; along with the viral, their 1000 words blog is interesting, allowing comments from the outside world (unlike an awful lot of brand blogs, which seem frightened that the consumer will play with/disrupt the brand), and also gets at another inalienable truth, that photos are about telling stories.
However, unlike colour, I don't think Kodak can effectively 'own' this space without seeming like they are harking back to a bygone era and overly targeting the ageing population. Give Kodak owners a reason to feel proud of the product, like Old Spice. They have waited a long time to go/market digital because they wanted to ensure that the colour process was spot on. There's part of the insight.
Another insight would be that Kodak photos aren't throwaway, unlike the majority of 'quick snaps' that take place with a digital camera. How digital cameras are used vs 35mill is like comparing Internet consumption with TV. It's just such a different ball-game. It is perhaps why the 'cameras for purists' angle could work to some extent - Kodak certainly have the associations to make it work.
However, by emphasising the colour credentials, I've learnt something. I didn't know the extent that Kodak had researched colour, much less that they had developed an alternative to the flat panel display screen, their self luminous OLED. There's something to shout about, and doesn't limit the market Kodak go after, unlike 'cameras for purists'. It's their patent as well, so they have a real point of difference. I'd organise my thoughts for Kodak around the strategic thought that should "Demonstrate how Kodak's unique colours allow people to capture their best memories" or something to that effect.
My initial thought for a tagline was something like 'Memories aren't disposable', but I think that doesn't emphasise the colour aspect well enough, and plays too much on the 'purists' angle again.
I take back what I said about the brand in the interview; that they are seemingly doomed - I really think Kodak (if marketed correctly) have a great chance at pushing on in the digital sector, even given the size of the competition. Sony/LG/Panasonic simply don't have the colour/imaging history that Kodak have. Find a way of exploiting that, and the brand could rise again.
I'm really keen to hear what others have to say about these two brands - any opinions/thoughts?
Musings on London..

Well, on my trip to London for the most recent interview and to go to Russell's latest coffee morning, I had all manner of interesting conversations with all sorts of people.
It was truly chock-full of bright and intelligent folks, with conversation topics ranging from meeting Steve Henry next week (best of luck with that - shoot me an email and let me know how you get on), to what not to say in an interview (going off on a massive tirade/complimenting ladies on their tops is apparently not best advised), critiques of what I was going to say in the aforementioned interview (thanks very much Jess - by the way, the magazine - Contagious - that she writes for is excellent, check out the link) and a bit of musing on the differences between old school account handling and new-age planning.
One interesting topic that came up with Russell and Jess was that of London geography. Now, not being a Londoner myself - just a humble denizen of Worcestershire at this stage - it was fascinating to learn about the city. For example: What resides at St Giles's Circus?
Centre Point, according to Russell. Learning about the Blue Points in Soho was also fascinating. I think I'm going to have to purchase Peter Ackroyd's book on London. Anyway, here are a few snaps of my journey down - featuring a little Regent St and some Berkeley Square - sadly no coffee morning shots. I'll leave those to Russell's post.
I'm also going to write about some of the topics discussed in my interview - I'd be really appreciative if the blogsphere felt like chiming in.
Thursday, January 11, 2007
The Banksy Brand..
xTuesday, January 09, 2007
iPhone communication thoughts..

Monday, January 08, 2007
Blog/Brand devotion..

I'd like to begin this post by saying a big get well soon to Marcus Brown. Having the foresight to bring a camera along to the doctors, let alone blog about it deserves some respect. I'm not sure I'd have done the same, but this just cements Marcus's legendary status.
Curiously, this also coincided with me reading Naked Conversations (the book's blog can be found here) and learning about the 'rules' for blogging, and how blogging frequently can help businesses put out the fire of negative publicity.
I'd like to extend this belief into more personal thing (touched on by the book). It's quite staggering, when you think about it - blogging voices seem to in some cases to subsume the 'real' or certainly cross over. If any one of my blogging friends suddenly stopped posting for a prolonged period of time, I'd wonder what had happened to them. Yet, with twitter and technology like it, we are now more connected than ever. Indeed, if a blogger was ever struck down with illness, I wonder how many would text twitter before doing anything else.
Becoming this devoted (or mildly insane, in the case of the latter example) would surely have tremendous implications. You'd become what Gladwell calls the 'Salesman' of the piece, inspiring an audience almost on the basis of your relentless blogging. And, as one of the book's examples cites, 'good' bloggers blog once or twice a day. I've resolved to do that, but it's not going well this year. Perhaps I should get a Yo-Yo. I do have a digital camera now though, so more random pictures will be forthcoming.
Going back to the book for a second; it references a chap who was interested (to put it mildly) in Treo's. If blogs can whip up high priests of the brand, think how much your product would benefit. Even entering into a conversation with your consumer would surely help - yes, even the flaming you'd probably receive at some point.
Indeed, this blog was initially begun as a highly self referential online CV. However, as it's matured/become more irreverent/posted about music, I hope it's done rather more than that. I would like to think now it's a conversation with the world, as well as an online record of all my thoughts, even if they aren't always strictly marketing or advertising focused - I have had difficulty reconciling normal situations to marketing or advertising scenarios, unlike Mr Godin. Still, I'm not paid as much as he is and am not published quite yet.
I think I'd feel quite sad to abandon it at this point, although I'm not about to take photos of myself on a hospital bed. Some conversations shouldn't include photos of me laid out - I'll leave that to the drunken Flickr photos.
Thursday, January 04, 2007
Music! Music for you!

A fool may talk, but a wise man speaks..

That fine quote came from Mr Jonson - the legend behind the Roaring Girl. It relates to a post I've been thinking about for a while, prompted by Amelia's post, which summed up what I've been thinking about brand conversation/s.
I'm going to have to go back on what I posted some months earlier. Not every brand can talk to a consumer. If a brand tries to have a conversation with a customer that doesn't want to listen/isn't interested in the first place, I don't believe it works all the time. I'm less than convinced by the recent HSBC campaign, for example.
It's a strategy ('what's your point of view', or in other words what they believe to be a natural extension of 'the world's local bank' - something which I felt resonated far more strongly with the consumer, getting to the heart of why people bank) which seems far more at home with the likes of The Independent or the Guardian rather than a global bank.
However, make it more pally, akin to the Barclay's campaign which Amelia refers to in her post, and it doesn't seem to work either. The bank 'voice' just either seems like mindless babble in the case of the latter - and God knows, I don't trust a bank which is staffed by muppets - or overly detached from cold hard finance. Perhaps staffed by philosophers? Hard core thinking about David Hume or Sartre won't make my money work harder, damnit...
Although, in this instance, I understand why the point of view campaign was adopted. As a campaign idea, it can be translated into millions of executions worldwide without losing its central message - that everyone will take a different approach to life, but attitudes towards finance remain unchanging.
On the bank thinking, perhaps that's why the Halifax campaign works so well - it's entertaining, and yet you still know it's about a bank. Albeit with employees who will undoubtedly be on Pop Idol in the next edition. But they certainly will care about giving you extra. It also echoes my thoughts about jingles.
'Matey'/'Chatty' tones work for Nuts, for WKD, for Innocent. Brands which the consumer feels can talk with. Crucially, they also OFFER something and are genuine about what it is. I get the impression with HSBC or Barclays, the consumer reaction will be 'Oh...' and promptly forget the ad, or distrust it.
Perhaps one of the reasons why brands have a seemingly endless room for discussion is that a myriad of positions seem to be able to adopted; yet those which get it so right or forge new territory often seem so obvious and straightforward.
It's why I was such a fan of 'the world's local bank'. It implicitly said 'yes, we understand people are different, and we understand these differences and can help', rather than opening the debate up farther.
Perhaps in 20 years time there will come a bank which will be so societally relevant that people will get conversational tactics. Perhaps, but I doubt it. Speak to me like a bank, and I'll listen.
Thursday, December 21, 2006
The best chart. Ever.
Wednesday, December 20, 2006
Ack! I've been tagged..
xTuesday, December 19, 2006
No fear. Or, a plea for old school Account Handlers..


So, to avoid this... I'm not going to propose disbanding departments, allowing the most snot nosed account person to create creative work, nor saying to the most socially awkward planner to present an hour presentation to the most important client. That'd just be silly. Structures of this sort exist for a reason, and searching for new ones is liking asking 'What came first, the chicken or the egg?' (Yes, one of the presentations in the sidebar really was on a hiding to nothing).
Sunday, December 17, 2006
Memes, jingles or songs that just won't go away..

Tuesday, December 12, 2006
Christmas ads of old..

Monday, December 11, 2006
Reflections - Or...how like your blog are you?

Sunday, December 10, 2006
Today is the greatest day I've ever known (thoughts on music)


All hail the mighty Potters..

Friday, December 08, 2006
Keeping my promise..
Tuesday, December 05, 2006
The Duck Hunt. Or how Graduate Ad Interviews Work..
Graduate interviews. Strange things, really.x

Or a complete hero:

Sunday, December 03, 2006
"No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better"
I think my credo could be misinterpreted as Zen-like rubbish. It's strange (and I'll come onto explain this in a little while) but I think it tries to combine diligence and effort with being free spirited, if that makes sense. One thing is for sure, it's not quite up to the standard of this Caddyshack clip about Zen:
I've always lived my life from the perspective of someone who has realised that I don't have the natural ability to instantly be the best at everything I do. Sounds obvious I know, but hell, I think credos are inherently simplistic.
For what it's worth, I like to think I'm a pretty good writer (although this blog may be proving otherwise), someone who is fairly well read, an adequate sportsman (ok, ok, a poor sportman in everything barring golf, football and badminton) and generally a good bloke to be around. As I've mentioned before, I'm a useful trivial pursuit player - I know a little bit about a lot of things.
This lack of innate natural ability (unless I have some fantastic tiddlywinks ability lurking in the background) has always meant that I've had to push myself harder in order to get the most out of my talents.
*Cue thoughts on interestingness, a la Beeker*
Beeker has chosen the second, beauty, to inform on her credo. Yet I think the first - truth - informs on my credo, if I'm honest.
Watch this:
Now, how does knowing the truth have anything to do with failure? Well, my argument to that is that it's incredibly important. Knowing who you are, or where something is coming from, is the cornerstone of how I think and act. It's not to say things cannot change. They can, and frequently do. But knowing the now, as much as is possible, means that you can 'fail better' and improve.
Beauty and rationality are both important, but I feel that the middle ground, the truth, better informs on who I am.
I can take leaps of faith, but equally, at times, need to believe something to see it, and my perception of beauty changes with the day. The truth changes as well, but of the three, it seems to me to be the most tangible, and as such, the heart of my thinking on life, brands, the universe or indeed, the Dalai Lama.




